I’m running out of time - please help me pick!!

Okay Reddit, I really need your help with this one! I’m running out of time to order a dress for my October 2025 wedding and I’m down to two strong contenders that I’m 50/50 on.

I went into the store intending to retry/buy option 1, the ball gown. I prefer an a-line/ball down style as it feels comfortable, elegant, classic, and safe. My cousin pulled option 2 and I agreed to try it on for fun, but when I stepped out of the fitting room my families’ jaws dropped so now I’m completely torn! Which dress do you personally like better?

For me, option 1 is so dreamy and classic, but option 2 is a little sexier and romantic. Equally nice but completely different looks! TIA!