What lip product do you use?

I never wear lipstick because I’ve always struggled with chapped lips. I prefer something moisturizing & leaves a tint but if there’s any moisturizing lipsticks I’ll gladly use them.

I love the way lipliner & tinted gloss looks but I feel like I need to reapply it every 30 minutes.

My favorite products: - rose Vaseline lip tub (super moisturizing & leaves a natural pretty pink stain) - NYX butter gloss (moisturizing but sometimes leaves a whiteish film?) - fresh Sugar lip balm (one of the best chapsticks I’ve used but the tint is too dark for my taste)

Am I better off using a lip stain and clear gloss overtop? Is there a holy grail product to moisturize my lips before lipstick?