Please help me choose 💕

I want to make my first big designer purchase and i narrowed it down to two bags - the Celine Triomphe and the YSL Puffer Toy). I am searching for a black bag for every day use and one that might be able to be dressed up as well (that’s the argument that currently speaks for the YSL bag).

Does anyone own one of the bags? How do they hold up? Do they scratch easily?

And would you think both of them are staple pieces that could be worn for several years?

If anyone has other suggestions, please also share. Price limit is maximum 4k euros.