How soon is too soon to transition from the dating app?

Recent interaction on a dating app. I just feel like I want to be excited/intrigued enough to give you my number because it equates to giving you access to my personal life. Which is something to be earned. If I met a guy in public, he’d have to do/say way more than this to get my number.

What do y’all think? Is the goal to immediately get off the app & experience the other person? Or do you need at least a relatively solid connection before moving to that next small step?