Prosthetic Collection and Squish Comparison

After I posted about my two Banana Prosthetics SP7s in regular and soft firmnesses, some folks requested a squish comparison. I decided I’d go ahead and show all the packers I own and compare how they each compress. Keep in mind these answers can (unfortunately) be very subjective, and it’s hard to tell how hard or soft something is over video! Likewise, the colors in the photos are fairly inaccurate to real life IMO (and worse in the GIFs due to compression). The second pic is a firmness ranking from hardest to softest, and the following are GIFs of compression and squish tests, respectively. I tried to use the same amount of compression on every prosthetic (same force) for the first GIF, and achieve the same amount of squish (necessary force) for every prosthetic in the second GIF. Below, the 00-xx numbers refer to silicone shore if I had that information, which is a more standardized firmness scale — any info I’ve provided is either from the listing or from talking to the manufacturers, but silicone of a specific shore can come out slightly firmer or softer based on different additives, to my understanding.

Here is the list: A - BatBites Toys Aux Stroker, custom color, 00-20 firmness, tight channel (I also have this stroker with the tight, short channel, not pictured) B - Banana Prosthetics S2 Long Stroker, shade likely T2 (secondhand), regular (~00-20) firmness C - New York Toy Collective Jack 2-in-1 Packer Stroker, “hazelnut” color, one firmness offered D - Banana Prosthetics SP7 Soft Packer, shade T1, soft (~00-10) firmness E - Banana Prosthetics SP7 Soft Packer, shade likely T2 (secondhand), regular (~00-20) firmness F - BatBites Toys Dominion Packer, Hellfire coloration, 00-20 firmness, small size G - Grammas Sausages Basic Bruhwurst, “light roast” color, old basic formula (single-pour, ~00-10), older 2D version H - Grammas Sausages F3+ Andoillette, “mid roast/custom” (secondhand), F3+ formula with durability layer, older 2D version I - BatBites Toys Dominion Packer, unnamed coloration, 00-20 firmness, mini size J - Trans Guy Supply The Lou STP, 01 color, one firmness offered K - The Wicked Hunt “Knox” T-dick cock ring/balls, unnamed coloration, 00-50 firmness, one size offered

Firmness ranking from most to least firm: 1 - K “Knox” 2 - J “The Lou” 3 - I “Dominion Mini,” B “BP S2,” E “BP SP7 regular” 4 - A “Aux” 5 - F “Dominion Small,” G “Basic Bruhwurst” 6 - D “BP SP7 soft” 7 - C “NYTC Jack 2-in-1” 8 - H “F3+ Andoillette”

These are a comparative ranking but definitely don’t scale! The Andoillette is softer than the Jack by a long shot, as you can see in the GIFs. Also, for each number, I arranged the packers from least to most sticky/tacky. The worst offenders for stickiness are the BP SP7 soft, followed by the NYTC Jack. All are manageable without cornstarch IMO but YMMV.

I wanted to do this comparison before my new STP Andoillette gets here, as I hope after that I will be downsizing my collection by a lot! Feel free to comment or DM to ask any questions you might have — I also have a Spouti and a BulletBriefs/Tranzwear Arrow that I’m happy to talk about (I’m pre-T with a fairly average build and urethra placement).

Hope this helps someone out there picking the right prosthetic for them, as many of y’all’s posts have done for me :​) happy packing!