Should I go matte or shiny?

I'm about to get my first pair of boots and normally I wear sneakers. I'm thinking of getting the brandy color Captians from the classic collection but don't know if i should pull the trigger because of how shiny they are. I LOVE the look and how shiny they are don't get me wrong but the thing I'm wondering is can I wear these with jeans and a t-shirt on occasion and not look out of place?