Mascara smudging NO MATTER WHAT

I am desperate - my mascara is always smudging. I have tried tubing, regular, and waterproof. Right now I'm wearing Benefit Fanfest and I do like it a lot, but it still smudges. I do my base with Lancome serum concealer, but I do not set it because it is very sheer and I usually don't use powder at all. I apply mascara first and then contour, blush, all my other products. I use a primer and setting spray over the primer before I put on the concealer. Most days, however, I do not wear it because frankly I'm too lazy and also my skin is rather clear on its own. Today I came back from an outing to smudges (I also decided to wear my concealer today). I will admit I purchased this mascara because I saw tons of reviews saying it didn't smudge/flake. Help! I am desperate. Primer: Elf Jellypop Setting Sprays: The blue ELF one and the Milani make it last Concealer: Lancome serum with the WHITE cap Mascara: Benefit fanfest