CFB All-Star Team
I created a roster that includes the best player from every CFB team (all time)
Rules:
One player from each team
Must be the best player of all time from the program (no exceptions except for when I feel like it)
The amount of players and positions on the final team is the same as the All-American award.
Any player in the final roster must be selected from the original list.
Current FBS programs only
Note: I had to take some team's second or third best player, as I needed to fill a position group (Sorry Florida and Central Michigan). This is all subjective, so if you disagree with my selections, let me know!
Edit: I have been informed that Beanie Wells is from Akron, and did not play for them. I fixed the mistake.
Air Force - Chad Hennings (DT)
Akron - Jason Taylor (DL)
Alabama - Derrick Thomas (DT)
App State - Armanti Edwards (QB)
Arizona - Ricky Hunley (LB)
Arizona State - Pat Tillman (S)
Arkansas - Lance Alworth (WR)
Arkansas State - Jerry Muckenstrum (LB)
Army - DeWitt Coulter (OL)
Auburn - Bo Jackson (RB/WR)
Ball State - Darius Hill (TE)
Baylor - Mike Singletary (LB)
Boise State - Ashton Jeanty (RB)
Boston College - Doug Flutie (QB)
Bowling Green - Bryan McClure (QB)
Buffalo - Khalil Mack (LB)
BYU - Steve Young (QB)
Cal - DeSean Jackson (WR)
Central Michigan - Novo Bojovic* (K)
Charlotte - Alex Highsmith (LB)
Cincinnati - Jason Kelce (OL)
Clemson - Brian Dawkins (DB)
Coastal Carolina - Grayson McCall (QB)
Colorado - Travis Hunter (WR/DB)
Colorado State - Rashard Higgins (WR)
Duke - George McAfee (RB/DB)
East Carolina - Chris Johnson (RB)
Eastern Michigan - Dave Pureifroy (DE)
FIU - T.Y Hilton (WR)
Florida - Lomas Brown (OL)
FAU - Devin Singletary (RB)
Florida State - Deion Sanders (DB)
Fresno State - Derek Carr (QB)
Georgia - Herschel Walker (RB)
Georgia Southern - Adrian Peterson (RB)
Georgia State - Robert Davis (WR)
Georgia Tech - Calvin Johnson (WR)
Hawaii - Colt Brennan (QB)
Houston - Pat Studstill (WR/P)
Illinois - Dick Butkus (LB)
Indiana - Earl Faison (DE)
Iowa - Alex Karras (DT)
Iowa State - Troy Davis (RB)
Jacksonville State - Ryan Pelliroux (QB)
JMU - Charles Haley (DE)
Kansas - Gale Sayers (RB)
Kansas State - Terence Newman (DB)
Kennesaw State - Chandler Burks (QB)
Kent State - Usama Young (S)
Kentucky - George Blanda (QB/K)
Liberty - Dwayne Carswell (TE)
ULL - Hall Davis (DE)
ULM - Jackie Harris (TE)
LA Tech - Terry Bradshaw (QB)
Louisville - Lamar Jackson (QB)
LSU - Glenn Dorsey (DT)
Marshall - Randy Moss (WR)
Maryland - Vernon Davis (TE)
Memphis - DeAngelo Williams (RB)
Miami (FL) - Ray Lewis (LB)
Miami (OH) - Ben Rothelisberger (QB)
Michigan - Charles Woodson (DB)
Michigan State - Bubba Smith (DE)
Middle Tennessee - Joe Campell (DE)
Minnesota - Bronco Nagurski (FB/DT)
Mississippi State - Fletcher Cox (DT)
Missouri - Drew Lock (QB)
Navy - Roger Staubach (QB)
NC State - Tory Holt (WR)
Nebraska - Dave Rimington (OL)
Nevada - Charles Mann (DE)
New Mexico - Brian Urlacker (LB)
New Mexico State - Chase Holbrook (QB)
North Carolina - Lawrence Taylor (LB)
North Texas - Ray Renfrow (RB)
NIU - Jordan Lynch (QB)
Northwestern - Otto Graham (QB)
Notre Dame - Joe Montana (QB)
Ohio - Todd Snyder (WR)
Ohio State - Orlando Pace (OL)
Oklahoma - Billy Sims (RB)
Oklahoma State - Barry Sanders (RB)
Old Dominion - Taylor Heinecke (QB)
Ole Miss - Eli Manning (QB)
Oregon - Haloti Ngata (DT)
Oregon State - Chad Johnson (WR)
Penn State - LaVar Arrington (LB)
Pitt - Tony Dorsett (RB)
Purdue - Rod Woodson (DB)
Rice - Jarett Dillard (WR)
Rutgers - Ray Rice (RB)
Sam Houston - Rhett Bomar (QB)
San Diego State - Marshall Faulk (RB)
San Jose State - Dwight Lowery (S)
SMU - Eric Dickerson (RB)
South Alabama - LaDamian Webb (RB)
South Carolina - Stephon Gilmore (CB)
South Florida - Jason Pierre-Paul (LB)
Southern Miss - Ray Guy (P)
Stanford - John Elway (QB)
Syracuse - Jim Brown (RB)
TCU - LaDainian Tomlinson (RB)
Temple - Joe Klecko (DT)
Tennessee - Peyton Manning (QB)
Texas - Ricky Williams (RB)
Texas A&M - Von Miller (LB)
Texas State - Jeremiah Haydel (WR)
Texas Tech - Patrick Mahomes (QB)
Toledo - Brent Williams (DE)
Troy - DeMarcus Ware (LB)
Tulane - Michael Pratt (QB)
Tulsa - Dennis Byrd (DT)
UAB - Roddy White (WR)
UCF - Brandon Marshall (WR)
UCLA - Troy Aikman (QB)
UMass - Victor Cruz (WR)
UNLV - Randall Cunningham (QB)
USC - Ronnie Lott (DB)
UTEP - Seth Joyner (LB)
UTSA - Marcus Davenport (DE)
Utah - Steve Smith (WR)
Utah State - Lionel Aldridge (DE)
Vanderbilt - Jay Cutler (QB)
Virginia - Heath Miller (TE)
Virginia Tech - Michael Vick (QB)
Wake Forest - Jessie Bates lll (S)
Washington - Steve Entman (DE)
Washington State - Drew Bledsoe (QB)
West Virginia - Bruce Irvin (LB)
Western Kentucky - Demaryious Thomas (WR)
Western Michigan - Greg Jennings (WR)
Wisconsin - Melvin Gordon lll (RB)
Wyoming - Josh Allen (QB)
* I needed a kicker
First Team All CFB
QB - Joe Montana (Notre Dame)
RB - Bo Jackson (Auburn)
RB - Jim Brown (Syracuse)
WR - Randy Moss (Marshall)
WR - DeSean Jackson (Cal)
WR - Calvin Johnson (Georgia Tech)
TE - Vernon Davis (Maryland)
OL - DeWitt Coulter (Army)
OL - Lomas Brown (Florida)
OL - Jason Kelce (Cincinnati)OL - Dave Rimington (Nebraska)
OL - Orlando Pace (Ohio State)
DT - Derrick Thomas (Alabama)
DT - Bronco Nagurski (Minnesota)
DT - Haloti Ngata (Oregon)
DE - Steve Entman (Washington)
DE - Bubba Smith (Michigan State)
LB - Dick Butkus (Illinois)
LB - Lawrence Taylor (North Carolina)
LB - Ray Lewis (Miami)
DB - Deion Sanders (Florida State)
DB - Charles Woodson (Michigan)
DB - Brian Dawkins (Clemson)
DB - Ronnie Lott (USC)
K - Novo Bojovic (Central Michigan)
P - Ray Guy (Southern Miss)
Returner - Gale Sayers (Kansas)