Comparison: Gen 4 V2 TB vs Huilian
When it comes to replica earbuds, the Gen 4 V2 TB and the Gen 4 V2 Huilian are two popular options from different manufacturers. Both excel in certain areas while having distinct characteristics. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose.
Connection
- TB: First time connection via double-tap was inconsistent, requiring a few tries to get it right.
- Huilian: Offers a smoother and more reliable connection process, making it the better option for ease of use.
Sound Effects (SFX)
- TB: The sound effects are too loud, like when changing from transparency mode to ANC, which can be jarring. If you’re sensitive to sharp sounds, this might become a drawback.
- Huilian: The sound effects are quieter but less polished. While not as refined as TB, they are less likely to overwhelm you.
Noise Floor
Both models handle idle noise decently, with differences in how the noise is perceived:
- TB: The noise floor has a static-like quality, noticeable but not intrusive.
- Huilian: The noise floor is quieter and has a more digital character, which blends in better and is less distracting overall.
Sound Quality
This is where the models diverge significantly:
- TB: Emphasizes bass, making it the better choice for bass lovers. However, the bass can feel overpowering and muddy, potentially masking other frequencies.
- Huilian: Offers a clearer and more balanced sound profile. The bass is present but can feel lacking at times, though this can be improved with EQ adjustments.
In short: TB is ideal for bass enthusiasts, while Huilian is better for those who prioritize clarity and balance.
Active Noise Cancellation (ANC)
Both models deliver excellent ANC performance, even without ear tips.
- TB: Strong and reliable ANC, effectively blocking ambient noise.
- Huilian: Equally strong ANC, making it hard to discern any meaningful difference between the two.
Final Thoughts
Both the Gen 4 V2 TB and Gen 4 V2 Huilian are strong contenders, with each catering to different preferences:
- TB: Perfect for users who love punchy bass and don’t mind louder sound effects or a static-like noise floor. However, the inconsistent connection process might be a drawback.
- Huilian: Best suited for those seeking a smoother connection, quieter noise floor, and clearer sound quality. The bass isn’t as powerful, but EQ adjustments can significantly improve it.
Ultimately, both models deliver excellent ANC and solid overall performance. Your choice will depend on whether you prefer powerful bass and louder SFX (TB) or balanced sound and ease of use (Huilian).
Currently there is a price difference of 10 USD, Huilian being the more expensive one. I don't think that Huilian is worth 30% more, so therefore I'd recommend the TB ones for now. If they were equally priced, I might have picked Huilian as the winner.
Build quality is very similar.